Children and worship

Someone asked this today: ” At what age do you believe children should be participants in the morning worship service? Our church is exploring options for extended session and are thinking through the theology on this as well as researching what other churches are doing.

I feel that there needs to be some kind of transition period where children are taught about worship experientially . . . . Thoughts?”

My response: Good question, and an important one. Here are some comments for pondering:

I think you’re starting at the right place, asking, “What’s our theology about this?” You should also consider developmental issues along with your theology of children, church, and worship.

Depending on the size of the church and the culture of the church, five-year-olds can handle “adult” worship. (MOST ethnic congregations do NOT take their children—of whatever age—out of the “adult” (read: community) worship experience. Are anglo children too stupid to do the same?).

First graders (around 6 or 7 years old) are emerging “readers”. They can handle the adult worship service, especially if the church accomodates them, and if parents take responsibility for teaching and modeling worship. (Some kindergarteners are emerging readers if they go to a good school system. But regardless, five-year-olds’ greatest need is “socialization” into the larger world. What better place for that than communal worship?).

Most churches take transition and rites-of-passage events (if they have any) from outside sources, like the school system. There are some pragmatic advantages to this, but often no theological ones. So, one option is to help your children make the transition into adult (community) worship halfway through their first grade year. This seems natural in many ways: their reading skills have developed by then, and the school’s “Spring break” can be re-claimed as the church’s “Easter break”. Older children (I HOPE OLDER!) are making a transition during that time through catechism and baptisms, why not a transition for the younger children? Wouldn’t it be neat for a family to mark the nodal events provided by these rites in their family? The older child getting baptized (the issue of the age for that is a topic for another discussion) and a passage into “community worship” for the younger one?

I like your emphasis on learning this “experientially.” As you know, “you learn to do what you do and not something else.” In this case, that thought suggest that while there may be some vaule in providing “pretend worship” for children, they will never REALLY learn to worship untill they participate fully in the community corporate worship experience. (That’s the reason I think attenpts to provide adolescents with “their own” worship service apart from the corporate worship is misguided. “What’s the theology behind that?”).

10-year-olds make excellent acolytes and can participate in being “worship leaders” in meaningful and significant ways—-with intentional and informed training.

I think there’s a handout on the CD I shared with the GRACE group, the “Teaching Handouts” CD, that contains teaching points to introducing young children to adult worship.

Any thoughts from other GRACE members?

galindobanner3.jpg

POST SUMMARY
Date posted: Wednesday, January 31st, 2007 7:29 pm | Under category: children
RSS 2.0 | Comment | Trackback
» 3 Comments

3 Comments

  1. jdmess said »

    If anyone knows me at all, they know how I feel about this issue. Children belong in worship and should not be sent out like second class citizens. I know you have issues you rant about but this one is my big issue. I do not understand the need to send children away in order to "teach" them about something happening in the other room. Worship is a community gathering and should exclude no one.

    As you know, I wrote my thesis on this very topic. I am not the first to think this way as Horace Bushnell is a good guide. Another pioneering group is Faith Inkubators out of Stillwater, MN. Their website is http://www.faithink.com and they have created a wonderful resource called Faith Stepping Stones that helps the church do the very thing you suggest which is marking events in the family’s life cycle within the context of worship.

    I do not want the comment to be longer than the original post so I shall end by simply saying, do not take children out of worship. Instead, learn from them about a pure, simple way to come into the presence of the Holy. Taking children out of worship during any part teaches the child to check out at the same time when they become an adult. We have congregations full of adults like that who don’t even challenge what a pastor says in the sermon.

    Okay, so I can’t stop on this particular issue but I feel strongly enough about this that I left a ministry position when I was challenged on this very issue!

  2. igalindo said »

    I love a good rant, Jon, so rant on.

    I had a chance to rant about this topic today at a conference at which I presented. I think that while most of the participants were challenged by my advocacy of keeping children in worship, and appreciated the rationale I presented, most struggled with wrapping their minds around the pragmatic logistics of keeping the kids in church and in working through the assumptions they have about keeping kids out of corporate worship.

    It was very hopeful to hear what some folks shared with me in private conversations after the conference. A couple of them "got it" and shared their attempts at being more conscientious about the inclusion of children in their worship.

  3. igalindo said »

    After yesterday’s conference (where I made several comments about children in the church), one person asked me a question along the lines of "What constitutes a ‘theology of children’"? He’d heard me mention the phrase and wanted to help his church be more informed about children in the church by clarifying a theology of children.

    I gave him as best an answer I could, along with some illustrations about how a theology can inform practice.

    Here’s a link to one religious group’s theology of children. I think it’s well done in that is contains some of the key elements that need to go into a "theology for …"

    http://www.directionjournal

Leave a Comment

Please note: Comment moderation is enabled and may delay your comment. There is no need to resubmit your comment.